Mendeleyev's Dream by Paul Strathern

Mendeleyev's Dream by Paul Strathern

When I started reading Mendeleyev's Dream: The Quest for the Elements a couple of years ago, I expected it to be a rather dry - and concentrated on chemistry and Mendeleyev - book. It turned out to be anything but.

The book starts with the culmination of Mendeleyev's Eureka! moment, and the immediate events surrounding it. However, next time Mendeleyev appears in the book is at the very end.

The book turned out to be a story about science in general - from early philosophers to Mendeleyev's periodic table. A lot has happened in between, and Paul Strathern does a rather remarkable job showing it to us.

Mendeleyev's Dream covers well over a dozen (if not several dozen) scientists and philosophers, whose discoveries (and personal lives, by will or by accident) led to the discovery ( was it discovery? It doesn't seem like the right word, for some reason. It wasn't exactly an invention either...) periodic table.

Some ideas and way of thinking may seem absurd to us these days. It's very possible that our understanding of the world will look as alien to humans several thousand (or even hundred) years later, but I would like to believe that scientific method, as a concept, is here to stay. Science is the best explanation of xyz phenomenon at the current moment based on the best evidence available to us now, and although some of our understanding may seem ridiculous down the road, the concept of a scientific, grounded logic seems like the right way to go.

Give it a try. The book is filled not only with scientific facts and discoveries, but also with stories from personal lives of the science "participants". It's not your regular science book. It's not dry. Recommended to everyone.

As always, ChatGPT generated the review below. It's accurate and reflects the essence of the book well.

-Marty

Paul Strathern's Mendeleyev's Dream delves into the history of chemistry, tracing humanity's quest to understand the fundamental building blocks of matter. The book offers a captivating journey from ancient philosophies to modern scientific discoveries, culminating in Dmitri Mendeleyev's formulation of the Periodic Table.

The narrative begins with early philosophical musings on the nature of matter, exploring the transition from alchemy to chemistry. Strathern introduces readers to key figures whose curiosity and experiments paved the way for modern science. The culmination of these efforts is highlighted in Mendeleyev's visionary creation of the Periodic Table, a unifying framework that revolutionized our understanding of the elements.

Key Takeaways

  • Evolution of Scientific Thought: The book illustrates the gradual shift from mystical explanations to empirical science in understanding the natural world.
  • Human Element in Science: Strathern emphasizes the personal stories, challenges, and idiosyncrasies of scientists who contributed to major breakthroughs.
  • Interconnectedness of Discoveries: The development of the Periodic Table is portrayed as a cumulative achievement, building upon centuries of inquiry and experimentation.

10 Intriguing Quotes Highlighting Unexpected Facts

  1. “Empedocles was to die when he leapt into the crater of Mount Etna, in an attempt to prove to his followers that he was immortal. Opinion remained divided at the time, but over the years his lack of reappearance went against him.”

     

  2. “In its early days philosophy included science – which became known as 'natural philosophy'. Thales' thinking was scientific because it could provide evidence for its conclusions. And it was philosophy because it used reason to reach these conclusions: there was no appeal to the gods or mysterious metaphysical forces.”

     
  3. “Thales of Miletus, the first philosopher-scientist. His theory that the world had developed from one element (water) was just the beginning. This idea, once conceived, was quickly developed by Thales’ pupils in Miletus – the philosophers known as the Milesian school.”

     
  4. “When Kirchhoff had studied sunlight with his spectroscope, he had detected a number of unaccountable dark bands in its spectrum. The light from the sun had to pass through its atmosphere, and he realized that these dark bands were the ‘fingerprints’ of the elements present there.”

     
  5. “Earlier, the French positivist philosopher Auguste Comte had pronounced that certain kinds of knowledge would remain forever beyond the reach of science. For instance, it would never be possible to discover precisely what the stars were made of.”

     
  6. “In 1981 the American physicist Murray Gell-Mann, inspired by Mendeleyev’s example, came up with a classification table for subatomic particles, which he named the eightfold way.”

     
  7. “What Mendeleyev discovered on 17 February 1869 was the culmination of a two-and-a-half-thousand-year epic: a wayward parable of human aspiration. In 1955 element 101 was discovered and duly took its place in the Periodic Table. It was named mendelevium, in recognition of Mendeleyev’s supreme achievement. Appropriately, it is an unstable element, liable to spontaneous nuclear fission.”

     
  8. “Between them, Kirchhoff and Bunsen developed the spectroscope, which uses a prism to refract light.”

     
  9. “Mendeleyev had realized that when the elements were listed in order of their atomic weights, their properties repeated in a series of periodic intervals. For this reason, he named his discovery the Periodic Table of the Elements.”

     
  10. “Here he briefly attended lectures by Gustav Kirchhoff, said to have been the most boring lecturer in all Germany at the time. (Some feat, considering.)”


Strathern's work offers a rich tapestry of scientific history, blending biographical sketches with the evolution of chemical knowledge. The selected quotes underscore the unpredictable and often surprising path of scientific discovery, highlighting the human elements—both triumphant and tragic—that have shaped our understanding of the elements.


Mendeleyev's Dream is recommended for readers interested in the history of science, particularly chemistry, and those who appreciate narratives that intertwine human stories with intellectual breakthroughs. Its engaging prose and insightful anecdotes make it accessible to both science enthusiasts and general readers seeking to understand the journey toward the Periodic Table.

Back to Blog
  • Share
  • facebook
  • icon_linkedin
  • icon_x